Netflix’s The Boyfriend is not just groundbreaking – it’s the antidote to Love Island (2024)

In an era of high-concept dating shows, the premise of Netflix’slatest Japanese offering,The Boyfriend,is a pretty simple one. A group of singles in their twenties and thirties move into a beautiful house for a few weeks in the summer; over that time, they hope that they’ll share a romantic spark with someone who might then become their partner.

What makesThe Boyfriendgroundbreaking, though, is that all the contestants are gay and bisexual men, making the series the first same-sex dating show based in Japan. The country is the only G7 nation that has not yet legalised same-sex marriage, despite polls suggesting that more than 70 per cent of the population would be in favour of doing so. Few Japanese celebrities feel able to come out, often fearing that opening up about their sexuality might damage their careers; media representation of the LGBT+ community often falls into flamboyant stereotypes.

Against this backdrop, a show like this one feels like a huge step forward in normalising queer relationships. After all, same-sex couples have been able to get married in Britain since 2014, and had the option to have a civil partnership for about 10 years before that, but it was only in2023that an all-gay dating show,I Kissed a Boy, aired on British TV (followed byI Kissed a Girl this year).

It’s also a leap of faith for the contestants too. We’re introduced to them in classic dating show style, with a quick montage of their life outside theseries, but their opening soundbites go much deeper than describing their type on paper. Taeheon, a designer from Korea, hasn’t spoken to his family about his sexuality yet, and is hoping that the series will give him the opportunity “to express myself openly and show my family who I really am”. Another contestant notes that he’s prone to closing himself off from potential partners, for fear of getting hurt. “If I’m vulnerable, I’ll grow,” he says. You don’t tend to get that in theLove Islandbeach hut confessionals.

The stakes are clearly high forthese contestants, so the producers don’t need to try to raise them artificially. There are no dramatic eliminations. The men seem to have been selected because they’re genuinely looking for love, rather than being picked out as TV troublemakers or wannabe celebs. Instead of taking part in sexed-up challenges that require them to start snogging before they’ve even committed each other’s names to memory, the group is given the rather sedate,Apprentice-esque challenge of running a coffee van together during their time in the house. The rationale is that by living and working alongside one another, they’ll get to properly see all the sides of their love interests’ personalities. There’s also a panel of commentators who sit in a studio, passing judgement on the interactions we’ve just watched, a bit like the “experts” inMarried at First Sight.

Sometimes, the men must excuse themselves from the shared house in order to deal with work commitments or just to meet up with their friends, making the set-up a much more authentic one than a hermetically sealed villa. The wholeapproachseems designed not to produce conflict but to slowly foster connection.And although it’s relatively low-drama (the biggest upset is over the cost of buying enough chicken to keep up one of the men’s protein intake), it certainly hooks you in. In the first episode, the contestants must write an anonymous note to the boy they’re most interested in and leave it in his personal mailbox. The next morning, everyone is clamouring to work out who wrote to who (and when some of them receive nothing at all, their responses are quietly heartbreaking).

Despite its sheer existence being a historic moment,The Boyfriendis entertainment, not activism. In the first few episodes, there are some brief nods to the challenges that gay people face in Japan, both in terms of finding partners and wider acceptance. But for the most part, the emphasis is on letting the men and their relationships speak for themselves, rather than straining for louder political statements. We’ll have to wait and see whether it will change attitudes in Japan – but it certainly gives us a blueprint for a different kind of dating show, one that’s the perfect antidote toLove Islandfatigue.